He's a sinking ship, you're a shining star
Him I want to rescue, but you would save my heart
He's a steady rock, but you're a blazing fire
He would hold me every night, but you would take me higher
No matter what I do, I can't have two

Tell me, how do I choose?
Is it him or is it you?
I can't keep going along like this
Either way I win and lose
Tell me, how do I choose?
Is it him or you, him or you?
Is it him or you, or is it you?

Whenever I'm with him, I always think of you
When I'm in your arms, I feel his too
So I got to know, before I lose you both
Which one I could let go, who I love the most
Should I follow my head or my heart?

Tell me, how do I choose?
Is it him or is it you?
I can't keep going along like this
Either way I win and lose
Tell me, how do I choose?
Is it him or you, him or you?
Is it him or you, or is it you?

I'm feeling guilty every day
With both your hearts inside my hands
Because I know that one of you
Is never gonna understand

Tell me, how do I choose?
Is it him or is it you?
I can't keep going along like this
Either way I win and lose
Tell me, how do I choose?
Is it him or you, him or you?
Is it him or you, or is it you?
Is it him or you, is it him or you?
Is it him or you, is it him or you, or is it you?
Or is it you, or is it you?